The Buck Stops Here: Truman vs the Generals

For a man who famously declared “The buck stops here,” Harry Truman sure found himself in a lot of arguments about where, exactly, that buck was stopping. Case in point: the Korean War. You can’t discuss that conflict without mentioning the other war it sparked—the one between President Truman and General Douglas MacArthur. The commander-in-chief and his top general had such a spectacular falling-out that Truman ultimately did what no one had dared to do before: he fired the five-star general.

If that sounds like a gutsy move, well, it was. It was also political napalm. To be fair, MacArthur was a bit of a prima donna, and Truman was not the first president with whom he clashed. MacArthur was welcomed home as a war hero, Truman’s approval ratings cratered. If he had entertained any dreams of running for a third term (yes, even though the 22nd Amendment had just been ratified, but it didn’t apply to him), those dreams were now as dead as his relationship with MacArthur.

When Truman left the White House in 1953, he handed it over to another general, Dwight D. Eisenhower. Once upon a time, Truman and Eisenhower had been professional allies, but by the time of Ike’s inauguration, their relationship had grown frostier than a Missouri winter. The proof? On the ride from the White House to the Capitol for the swearing-in ceremony, the two men barely spoke. It was the world’s most awkward car ride with the entire nation watching.

Two Generals, One Common Cause

Two generals. Two adversaries. Two very different clashes with a very determined president. But here’s where the plot twist comes in: despite their differences, Truman and Eisenhower did agree on one thing—something so crucial that it altered the course of world history. That something was the Marshall Plan.

Find out more about Harry Truman and the Marshall Plan at the Harry S. Truman Presidential Library and Museum

Now, for those who snoozed through history class, the Marshall Plan was a massive U.S. initiative to rebuild war-torn Europe after World War II. It was basically America’s way of saying, “Here, take this money, try not to starve, and don’t let communism seduce you.” It wasn’t just about charity—it was about securing the West against Soviet influence. Truman championed it. Eisenhower supported it.

That key issue united two political adversaries, but it also played a major role in affecting the destiny of the nation in another surprising way.

Eisenhower’s Political Awakening

In 1952, both Republicans and Democrats were begging Eisenhower to run for president. The man was a war hero, respected by all, and, most intriguingly, no one was entirely sure what his political leanings were. In a country still reeling from the Great Depression and a world war, he was the ultimate political Rorschach test—people saw whatever they wanted to see.

But there was one person who definitely knew what he wanted: Senator Robert Taft of Ohio. He was the Republican frontrunner for the presidential nomination, and he was staunchly opposed to the Marshall Plan. That put him at odds with Eisenhower. And Ike? Well, he wasn’t about to let the Marshall Plan go down without a fight.

Eisenhower approached Taft and made him an offer. If Taft would publicly support the Marshall Plan, Ike agreed to withdraw his name from consideration for the presidency, leaving the Republican nomination wide open for Taft to take.

Taft, a man of unshakable principles, thought about it, mulled it over, and then said, “Nope.” He just couldn’t bring himself to back the plan.

And that, ladies and gentlemen, is the moment history pivoted.

With Taft unwilling to budge, Eisenhower stepped into the race, secured the Republican nomination, and steamrolled his way to the presidency in a landslide victory. The Marshall Plan remained a centerpiece of U.S. foreign policy, thanks to the unlikely alliance of Truman and Eisenhower.

The Final, Unexpected Twist

By the time Eisenhower took the oath of office, Truman and Ike were no longer on speaking terms. Their once-warm relationship had turned ice-cold, and the silent car ride to the Capitol was just the cherry on top of the we-are-not-friends sundae.

But fate had one more trick up its sleeve.

Not long after Eisenhower became president, Robert Taft—the man who would have been the Republican nominee if not for the Marshall Plan standoff—died. That’s right. Had history taken a slightly different turn, Taft would have been elected, only to pass away in office.

And his vice president? The man who would have taken the reins of power?

None other than General Douglas MacArthur.

That’s right. The very same MacArthur who had been fired by Truman and who loomed over American politics like a vengeful specter. Had Taft lived just a little longer, MacArthur could have found himself at the helm of the nation.

Cue the theme song for the Twilight Zone.

In the end, history played out in ways no one could have predicted. Truman feuded with both MacArthur and Eisenhower. He won one battle and lost the other. But the one victory he and Eisenhower both shared—the success of the Marshall Plan—helped shape the postwar world.

So while their car ride to the Capitol may have been awkward, at least they had something to be proud of. Even if they refused to talk about it.

---