Despite what has been endlessly repeated in children’s books and even some history textbooks, popcorn was not served as part of the first Thanksgiving menu in 1621. That legend appears to have popped up in the 19th century, supported by enthusiasm but not evidence.

Also missing from that table were mashed potatoes, pumpkin pie, and anything resembling modern cranberry sauce. Sugar was scarce, ovens were limited, and nobody was whipping cream for decorative purposes.

Turkey, contrary to popular belief, was not necessarily absent, but it also was not the star of the show. Contemporary accounts refer only to “fowl,” which could have included duck, goose, or turkey.

What we do know is that the meal featured venison, wild fowl, and locally available foods such as corn, squash, and beans. It was less a Norman Rockwell painting and more a practical celebration of not having starved.

As for utensils, forks had not yet made their grand entrance into the Pilgrims’ daily lives. The meal was eaten with spoons, knives, and fingers—proof that even in 1621, some traditions refuse to change.

source

---