The Real-Life Story of Agatha Christie’s Greatest Unsolved Mystery

Agatha Christie’s name is synonymous with mysteries. The author of such classics as Murder on the Orient Express, The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, and Death on the Nile, her novels have sold more than 2 billion copies. Her most popular novel, And Then There Were None, has sold more than 100 million copies. Guinness World Records identifies her as the best-selling fiction author of all time. Index Translationum recognizes her as history’s most-translated individual author.

Agatha Christie, circa 1946

Having firmly established her legacy as the queen of mystery, it shouldn’t be surprising that mystery seeped into her personal life. As if scripted for an Agatha Christie novel, a chapter in her life blurred the distinction between the pages of a novel and those of a newspaper. In classic Christie form, she left this mystery for the world to ponder and attempt to figure out for itself. Nearly fifty years after her death, pundits still debate what happened in the greatest unsolved Agatha Christie mystery.

Agatha Mary Clarissa Miller was born September 15, 1890, in Torquay, Devon, United Kingdom. When she was 22 years old, she met Archibald “Archie” Christie. Three months after meeting, the couple became engaged. They were married on December 24, 1914.

Archie was a pilot with the Royal Flying Corps. When World War I broke out, he was sent to France for combat. Agatha worked as a member of the Voluntary Aid Detachment of the Red Cross as a nurse and apothecaries’ assistant. When she was not working, she dealt with the loneliness by pursuing a lifelong love of writing. In 1916, she wrote her first detective novel, The Mysterious Affair at Styles. The story featured a man who would become second only to Sherlock Holmes in the world of literary detectives, Hercule Poirot.

Although her first manuscript was rejected, she persisted in writing. The Mysterious Affair at Styles was published in 1920, the first of what would become 66 detective novels that would make Agatha Christie a household name throughout the world.

Archie returned from the war in 1919. As Agatha’s books grew in popularity, the couple’s financial status improved dramatically. Even so, Agatha took firm control over all family expenses. Some suggest this is the reason for the marital difficulties experienced by the couple. Others point to Archie’s inability to cope with his wife being the primary breadwinner. Whatever the reason, Archie and Agatha grew increasingly distant as the 1920s progressed.

In August 1926, the tension in the Christie home had become unbearable. Archie began an affair with his 25-year-old secretary, Nancy Neale. He told Agatha he was in love with Nancy and wanted a divorce. Agatha was heartbroken but was unwilling to declare their marriage dead.

Four months later, on December 3, Archie announced he would be spending the weekend with some friends and that Agatha was definitely not invited to come along. The offended wife objected — loudly. They quarreled until Agatha stormed out of the home.

It was the next morning that the events of real-life seemed to be dictated from one of Agatha’s manuscripts. Her automobile was found several miles from the Christie home. Parked above a chalk quarry at Newlands Corner, the car’s headlights were on. Inside, police found Agatha’s expired driver’s license, a suitcase, and some clothes. As for the mystery writer, she was nowhere to be found.

Overnight, Agatha Christie’s name moved from book covers to newspaper headlines. A reward was offered for any information that might lead to finding her. All signs pointed to foul play, with police suspecting the worst.

Immediately, detectives focused their attention on the most likely suspects: Archie Christie and his trophy girlfriend, Nancy Neale. As the police questioned them repeatedly, the search for Agatha moved into high gear. More than 1,000 police officers and about 15,000 volunteers combed woods, fields, and abandoned buildings, looking for any sign of the missing writer. Authorities dredged a local lake known as the Silent Pool, suspecting they might find Agatha’s lifeless corpse at the bottom.

None of the searches produced any helpful information. The police reached for outside assistance under pressure from Home Secretary William Joynson-Hicks. Fellow mystery author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle offered his assistance and employed the services of a clairvoyant to find Agatha.

For ten days, the world was gripped by the mystery concerning the mystery writer. Just as the police were beginning to give up hope of finding her, they received a surprising call from a waiter at the Hydropathic Hotel in Harrogate, Yorkshire. He told them that one of the hotel’s guests, a South African woman by the name of Tressa Neale, bore a striking resemblance to the woman whose face had been in every newspaper.

Detectives traveled the 184 miles (296 km) to Yorkshire with Archie Christie in tow. Quietly, they took up position at a corner table in the hotel’s dining room and waited. Much to everyone’s surprise, the famous Agatha Christie walked into the restaurant, took a seat, and casually flipped through a newspaper that heralded the story of her disappearance on its front page.

Archie approached Agatha’s table to speak with her. The detectives reported that she seemed puzzled and did not seem to recognize the man who had been her husband for a dozen years.

The detectives brought Agatha from the hotel to her sister’s home the next day. There she remained under medical observation, as physicians attempted to diagnose her bizarre behavior. Rumors immediately began to fly that her disappearance was an elaborate publicity stunt. Others suggested that she had been in some sort of accident that affected her memory.

As word of Archie’s affair came to light, others saw events in a different light. Could Agatha have staged her disappearance in a devious plot to frame her husband for murder?

Nearly half a century has passed since the mysterious event and there is yet to emerge any consensus about what really happened. Two of Agatha’s physicians concluded she had experienced “an unquestionable genuine loss of memory.” Others have suggested she suffered a nervous breakdown over the disintegration of her marriage. One researcher concluded she intended to embarrass her husband but underestimated how much publicity the stunt would generate. If so, that would explain her decision to register at the hotel with the last name of her husband’s mistress. Still others are firmly convinced that she planned the whole thing to make it appear that she had been murdered by Archie and Nancy.

Whatever happened, it did nothing to save the Christie marriage. She and Archie were divorced in 1928. Archie and Nancy married one week after the divorce was finalized.

As for herself, Agatha was quite vague and made little mention of the incident in her autobiography, other than to say, “So, after illness, came sorrow, despair, and heartbreak. There is no need to dwell on it.”

With all witnesses gone and no one remaining with first-hand knowledge of this strange chapter, the greatest Agatha Christie mystery remains unsolved.

First Assault on a President and a Timely Assist From Headless Horseman Writer

As George Washington took the reins of government as the first President of the United States, some thought it would be wise to create a permanent protective detail for the chief executive. The idea was dismissed, however. Since the President was chosen by the will of the people, it was unthinkable that anyone would attempt…

Keep reading

The Curse of James Dean’s Porsche

The death of James Dean on September 30, 1955, sent shock waves through Hollywood. The 24-year-old actor was cut down in the prime of life when he was involved in a head-on collision near Cholame, California. Despite his death at such a young age, Dean’s legend lives on. Another enduring legend relates to the car…

Keep reading

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.