Victorian portrait of Lewis Carroll, his head opening into Wonderland with Alice, the White Rabbit, Cheshire Cat, mushrooms and playing cards amid shimmering zigzag migraine aura.

Lewis Carroll gave us a rabbit with chronic scheduling difficulties, a cat that could disappear without bothering to take its grin along, and a queen whose preferred solution to practically every problem was a public execution. He also gave us a little girl who could grow to the size of a house, shrink to the dimensions of a particularly ambitious hamster, and carry on perfectly serious conversations with animals who had no business speaking English.

For more than 160 years, readers have admired the imagination behind Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. Naturally, rather than accepting that its author possessed an extraordinary creative mind, we have devoted considerable intellectual energy to asking whether something was wrong with his head.

To be fair, there is a legitimate medical mystery here. Lewis Carroll experienced disturbing visual phenomena consistent with migraine aura, and some researchers have suggested that his migraines helped inspire Wonderland. The resemblance between Alice’s adventures and certain neurological symptoms is so remarkable that doctors eventually named a real condition Alice in Wonderland syndrome.

There’s just one problem. Actually, there are several, but in the interest of keeping you with us for the entire journey, we’re going to introduce them one at a time.

Before Wonderland, There Was a Respectable Oxford Mathematician

Lewis Carroll was not born Lewis Carroll. He was born Charles Lutwidge Dodgson on January 27, 1832, and grew up to become a mathematics lecturer at Christ Church, Oxford. He was deeply interested in logic, puzzles, photography, word games, and the sort of mathematical problems that cause ordinary people to announce that they suddenly remember an appointment elsewhere.

Even his pen name required more effort than most of us put into naming our children. He translated Charles Lutwidge into the Latin Carolus Ludovicus, reversed the order, and translated the names back into English as Lewis Carroll. He offered possible pseudonyms to his publisher, who selected that one. Apparently, simply calling himself Charlie Dodgson would have deprived the enterprise of an entirely unnecessary but satisfying linguistic obstacle course.

Dodgson kept his identity as an Oxford scholar separate from the author of children’s nonsense. He was so committed to this arrangement that correspondence addressed to Lewis Carroll at Christ Church could meet with the response that no such person lived there. Technically, he had a point. Practically, it must have been frustrating for anyone trying to send him a fan letter.

His dual identity tells us something about how his mind worked. The man who invented Wonderland was not a stranger to rules; he taught rules for a living. As a mathematician, he understood how an argument could be constructed step by step, and as a humorist, he understood the pleasure of following those steps until they led straight off a cliff.

One could also argue that unusual neurological experiences may have contributed to his fiction. What one cannot responsibly do is pretend that his considerable artistic gifts disappear the moment a doctor enters the room.

One Boat Trip, Three Girls, and an Extremely Important Rabbit

On July 4, 1862, Dodgson and the Reverend Robinson Duckworth took the three Liddell sisters, Lorina, Alice, and Edith, on a boating excursion near Oxford. During the outing, Dodgson entertained the girls with a story about a young girl named Alice who followed a white rabbit into a most unreasonable world. Alice Liddell was so delighted that she asked him to write it down.

This is worth remembering the next time a child asks us to tell a story. We might produce a literary masterpiece, although our more typical results involve explaining why a dinosaur cannot drive the school bus and then trying to remember whether we’d already established that the dinosaur was a vegetarian.

Dodgson started putting the adventure into manuscript form later that year. He expanded and illustrated it, eventually presenting Alice Liddell with a handwritten copy titled Alice’s Adventures Under Ground in November 1864. Encouraged to publish it, he developed the story further and enlisted the artist John Tenniel to create the illustrations.

The first printing of Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland appeared in July 1865. Unfortunately, Tenniel disliked how his illustrations had reproduced, so the printing was withdrawn and replaced.

Carroll followed it with Through the Looking-Glass, published at Christmas 1871 with an 1872 date on its title page. The new adventure involved a world arranged around chess, another enterprise in which eccentric characters follow intricate rules while occasionally attacking one another.

By then, Carroll had created an enduring literary universe from storytelling, deliberate revision, mathematical playfulness, and some memorably peculiar illustrations. The migraine theory would arrive much later. For the moment, the only medical emergency in Wonderland was Alice’s tendency to change size without consulting a physician.

Alice Grows, Shrinks, and Gives Neurologists Something to Talk About

Consider Alice’s adventures from the perspective of someone who has never read the books. A girl drinks from a bottle labeled “DRINK ME” and becomes tiny. She eats a cake marked “EAT ME” and grows enormously. Later, she discovers that different sides of a mushroom can alter her size in opposite directions.

At this point, we feel obliged to offer the usual safety announcement from the Commonplace Fun Facts Senior Executive Vice President In Charge of Unwieldy Titles and Unnecessary Legal Disclaimers: Do not consume unidentified liquids, mysterious cakes, or mushrooms supplied by argumentative insects. We recognize that such advice would eliminate roughly half of Wonderland’s plot, but our legal department has never been especially supportive of creative expression.

In the story, Alice’s transformations are literal. She really does become larger and smaller within the fictional world. But outside fiction, some people experience a startlingly similar sensation without their bodies changing at all.

Neurological disturbances can make objects appear much smaller or larger than they are. The terms micropsia and macropsia describe certain distortions of perceived size. Other symptoms affect how a person perceives the proportions, position, or size of their own body. A hand may seem enormous; a room may appear impossibly distant; a familiar doorway may suddenly look as though it was built for a mouse with expensive architectural tastes.

These experiences can occur in several medical conditions, including some migraine episodes. They are not merely colorful ways of describing pain. The person experiencing them may know intellectually that nothing has changed, while the brain continues delivering a thoroughly unhelpful report on what reality looks like.

We covered the wider neurological oddities in our article on weird migraine facts. For now, our concern is not the complete catalog of migraine symptoms. It is whether Lewis Carroll might have experienced something sufficiently strange to furnish material for his fiction.

Unfortunately, comparing a fictional transformation with a real perceptual distortion does not tell us which came first, whether the author experienced it, or whether the resemblance is anything more than a remarkable coincidence. Those are the questions that turn an entertaining observation into a genuine historical mystery.

Lewis Carroll’s Migraines: The Fortifications Nobody Built

Carroll kept diaries, and some entries describe severe headaches and unusual visual experiences. The most frequently discussed evidence is an 1885 entry in which he said he had experienced, for the second time, an optical disturbance involving moving fortifications, followed by a headache.

This may sound as though Carroll was witnessing a siege from the comfort of his own skull. In fact, “fortification spectrum” is a historical medical description for an especially distinctive visual phenomenon. It refers to shimmering, jagged, often expanding patterns that resemble the angular walls and bastions of old-fashioned military fortresses.

For someone experiencing a migraine aura, a zigzag shape may seem to shimmer or move across part of the visual field. Portions of sight may become obscured or distorted, and the phenomenon can be followed by headache. The image is often so unusual that sufferers can describe it vividly many years afterward, assuming they have not chosen to forget the entire experience on principle.

Carroll’s account sounds strikingly like migraine aura. It is one reason physicians and historians have considered the possibility that he experienced migraines. Yet even here we should retain a degree of caution: nobody examined him using modern diagnostic criteria, and the surviving evidence of his headaches and other illnesses does not justify absolute certainty about every episode.

More importantly, seeing zigzagging lights is not the same as feeling that one’s arms have become thirty feet long. A visual aura resembling moving fortifications does not establish that Carroll experienced the body-size distortions associated with Alice in Wonderland syndrome.

At this point, we could simply declare the connection proven, congratulate ourselves on solving a 160-year-old mystery, and adjourn to the snack table. Unfortunately, a small detail has wandered into the proceedings carrying a large calendar.

There’s a Slight Problem: The Dates Are in the Wrong Order

Remember the timeline. Carroll told the original Alice story in 1862, published Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland in 1865, and brought out Through the Looking-Glass in 1871. His much-discussed diary description of moving fortifications dates from 1885.

In other words, the clearly documented episode came twenty years after the first book had been published. This does not mean Carroll never experienced something similar earlier. He called the 1885 occurrence his second, and that alone tells us there had been at least one previous episode of some kind.

But the record does not give us permission to place the necessary symptoms in the early 1860s merely because doing so would improve the story. Whenever we’ve tried this technique with other historical mysteries, our readers have been quick to remind us of their tiresome insistence upon historical accuracy.

There is another complication: the fact that someone has experienced migraine aura does not prove that the experiences caused or contributed to an imaginative work. Creative people draw upon observation, reading, jokes, memories, and things they invent for no reason beyond the pleasure of inventing them. The existence of one possible source does not eliminate the others.

So is the theory defeated? Not quite. Like the Cheshire Cat, it has a habit of disappearing just when we think we’ve cornered it, then reappearing somewhere inconvenient. The next clue takes us back to the 1850s, before Wonderland had been written at all.

The Strange Case of the Man Who Wasn’t Entirely There

Long before Alice took her first inadvisable sip from a mysterious bottle, the man who would become Lewis Carroll was helping to create a family magazine called Mischmasch. It contained poems, stories, drawings, and other material calculated to amuse the Dodgson household. Think of it as an early family newsletter, except that it involved actual creativity rather than six pages announcing that everyone had been very busy.

Among its illustrations is a drawing, believed to date from sometime between 1855 and 1862, of a standing man whose head and raised arm appear to be partially erased. Portions of the man’s face and hand are missing. It is the sort of picture that might prompt a concerned observer to ask whether the artist had run out of pencil, lost interest, or started drawing during a neurological episode.

In 1999, researchers Klaus Podoll and Derek Robinson examined the illustration as part of their investigation into Carroll’s possible migraine experiences. They suggested that the vanished sections resembled a scotoma, an area of impaired or missing vision that can occur during migraine aura.

Picture someone looking at a person while part of the visual field temporarily disappears. If the artist then attempts to draw what he actually sees, the result could contain a missing face, shoulder, or hand. That makes the illustration potentially important: it may predate the original Alice story of 1862, which would make it especially relevant to the theory that Carroll experienced migraine-like visual disturbances before creating Wonderland.

The researchers also noted that Dodgson consulted the ophthalmologist William Bowman in 1856 about an eye problem. The consultation adds an intriguing medical fact to the sketch, although the surviving reference does not establish what condition Bowman believed Dodgson had.

But we must consider the alternative explanation that the drawing was supposed to be funny. This was, after all, a man who later invented a cat capable of disappearing until nothing remained but its grin. A partially missing gentleman may have been a neurological clue. He may also have been a partially missing gentleman because that was the joke.

We are particularly sympathetic to this possibility because our own artistic efforts have produced images that could easily be mistaken for evidence of serious neurological trouble. We still bear the emotional scars of discovering that we had used the wrong crayon to color Spider-Man’s uniform. Colorblindness, thou art a cruel and heartless mistress!

The sketch and eye appointment keep the migraine theory alive, but neither proves that Dodgson experienced Alice-like sensations of growing and shrinking. We have a plausible piece of circumstantial evidence, not a signed confession from a migraine with a detailed account of its contributions to English literature.

How Alice in Wonderland Became an Actual Medical Condition

Here is where the story becomes gloriously backward. Regardless of whether migraine inspired Wonderland, Wonderland unquestionably inspired the name of a medical syndrome. It is an excellent example of literature getting its revenge on the scientific establishment.

In 1952, American physician Caro Lippman described migraine patients who experienced extraordinary distortions of their own body image. Some felt abnormally large or small. Familiar anatomy seemed to stretch, shrink, or rearrange itself without asking permission from its owner.

Three years later, British psychiatrist John Todd published a paper discussing similar perceptual disturbances and called the collection of symptoms “The Syndrome of Alice in Wonderland.” He described six patients whose experiences involved distortions of body image and related perceptions, often associated with migraine or epilepsy.

Thus was born Alice in Wonderland syndrome, also known as AIWS. The name is memorable, descriptive, and far more inviting than whatever collection of Greek and Latin syllables might otherwise have been assembled to describe the experience.

It is important to understand that this is not merely another name for a headache. Alice in Wonderland syndrome describes unusual disturbances of perception, especially the sense of bodily size and shape, and it has been reported in connection with various medical and neurological conditions. Migraine is an important association, but it is not the only one.

Nor does the syndrome demonstrate that its literary namesake was based on Carroll’s medical history. Physicians recognized that some patients’ symptoms resembled Alice’s adventures, so they borrowed her name. That is a relationship between a fictional story and a diagnosis—not proof that the diagnosis explains the story’s creation.

Confusing the two leads us into a wonderfully circular argument. Alice’s adventures resemble certain symptoms; the symptoms are named after Alice; therefore, Alice must have been inspired by the symptoms. This might pass muster at the Queen of Hearts’ court, where judgment is often a formality preceding punishment, but the rest of us should probably demand a little more evidence.

There is real suffering behind the entertaining name, of course. Distorted perception can be frightening, and anyone experiencing sudden unexplained neurological symptoms deserves proper medical attention rather than a diagnosis from a website that devotes an unreasonable amount of time to talking cats. Our internal medical department specifically requested that sentence. Admittedly, the department consists entirely of an unpaid intern who consults WebMD when he isn’t otherwise occupied making coffee, washing the Editor-in-Chief’s car, or answering increasingly angry emails from a reader who keeps demanding an explanation for why we used an AI-generated image instead of an actual photograph of the 1314 Battle of Bannockburn. Nevertheless, on this occasion we agree with him.

What If Lewis Carroll Was Just Really Good at Nonsense?

We have spent a good deal of time hunting through headaches, diaries, optical disturbances, and Victorian illustrations. It is only fair to give the author himself an opportunity to explain his own imagination—or at least to consider what we already know about his extraordinary interests.

Carroll was a mathematician and logician who knew how words and rules can be turned against themselves. Wonderland is full of arguments that begin sensibly and arrive at absurd destinations through an impeccable sequence of misunderstandings. The characters aren’t simply behaving at random. Quite often, they are following their own peculiar logic with admirable determination.

Take the Mock Turtle’s education. He describes classes in “Reeling and Writhing” and branches of arithmetic called “Ambition, Distraction, Uglification, and Derision.” These are not the accidental noises of a disordered brain. They are deliberate parodies of the lessons and improving literature familiar to Victorian schoolchildren.

Admittedly, “Ambition, Distraction, Uglification, and Derision” sound suspiciously like the four stages in a blogger’s development.

Or consider the creatures’ obsession with precise definitions. Carroll loved extracting unexpected consequences from everyday expressions, then forcing his characters to live with them. The result is a universe where nearly everyone has a logical reason for being completely unreasonable.

In Through the Looking-Glass, the action is arranged around a chess game, with Alice advancing toward becoming a queen. Even in his most fantastical moods, Carroll apparently couldn’t resist installing an underlying system of squares, moves, and rules. The mathematics lecturer had escaped the classroom, but he had brought the lesson plan with him.

For a related exercise in mathematicians making simple things magnificently complicated, we invite readers to consider why proving that one plus one equals two required hundreds of pages of mathematical groundwork. It is an excellent reminder that when mathematicians say something is obvious, the rest of us may wish to check our calendars before asking them to explain.

Carroll was also writing within a long tradition of literary fantasy and satire. In Gulliver’s Travels, Jonathan Swift had already imagined the practical and political complications of a man becoming gigantic among tiny people and insignificant among giants. Changing a character’s scale was a powerful literary device well before anyone associated Alice with migraine.

This does not rule out a personal medical influence. Great writers routinely transform their own experiences into fiction. But no single unusual perception can account for Carroll’s language games, brilliant dialogue, structural ingenuity, and the cast of characters who continue to occupy popular culture more than a century after his death.

Migraines are relatively common. Producing the Cheshire Cat is not.

Six Impossible Things Before Breakfast, Including One of Our Own

In Through the Looking-Glass, Alice tells the White Queen that there’s no use trying to believe impossible things. The Queen replies that Alice simply hasn’t had enough practice, explaining that in her youth she sometimes believed as many as six impossible things before breakfast.

The distinction between believing and dreaming is worth mentioning, particularly because the first version of this subject appeared in our own 2014 article about six impossible things before breakfast. That title substituted dreaming for believing, and the article rather confidently declared that Carroll suffered migraines for most of his life and that his aura inspired Wonderland’s strange characters.

We have since discovered that our younger editorial staff occasionally allowed an excellent story to outrun the available evidence the historical record supports a more nuanced interpretation. Our Department of Retrospective Editorial Wisdom has filed the necessary paperwork, although nobody knows where the department keeps its filing cabinet.

We still think the original theory is fascinating. We simply no longer think that fascination entitles us to issue a definitive medical diagnosis of a Victorian mathematician or to credit a migraine with creating a fictional universe when the evidence doesn’t establish that connection.

The White Queen might consider that an unnecessarily fussy approach. Then again, her willingness to believe six impossible things before breakfast is precisely the habit historians are supposed to resist. Believing something because it makes a splendid story is one thing. Demonstrating that it actually happened is quite another.

So Did Lewis Carroll’s Migraines Inspire Wonderland?

Here is what we can reasonably say. Lewis Carroll recorded visual disturbances that resemble migraine aura. A curious drawing from the 1850s and a visit to an eye specialist raise the possibility of earlier problems. Certain episodes in his fiction resemble perceptual distortions associated with a medical condition that eventually borrowed Alice’s name.

What we cannot say with confidence is that Carroll experienced the characteristic body-size distortions himself, that his symptoms preceded the creation of Wonderland, or that a migraine supplied the inspiration for his extraordinary stories. Those are intriguing possibilities, not established facts.

Perhaps migraines gave Carroll some unusual raw material. Perhaps he encountered the same ideas through literature, observation, and play. Or perhaps the greatest mystery of all is why we find it easier to credit a neurological disturbance than to accept that an exceptionally gifted writer had an exceptionally gifted imagination.

Whatever the truth, there is a pleasing irony here. Carroll invented a world in which ordinary reality refused to behave itself. Decades later, doctors encountered patients whose perceptions behaved almost as strangely, and they named the condition after his fictional heroine. The medical profession didn’t necessarily explain Wonderland; Wonderland helped the medical profession explain something else.

We suspect Carroll would have appreciated that reversal. And if someone insisted on a final, unquestionable answer, he might have referred the matter to the Cheshire Cat, whose chief advantage in any debate is the ability to disappear before anyone asks a follow-up question.


You may also enjoy…

Understanding Exploding Head Syndrome

One of the coolest-sounding disorders is fortunately not nearly as serious as its name suggests. Exploding Head Syndrome is a condition that causes people to hear extremely loud noises — a gunshot, an explosion, a thunderclap — as they’re drifting off to sleep, or as they wake up from a deep sleep. Such incidents are…

Keep reading

When The World’s Great Authors Formed a Cricket Team

What do literary giants do when they aren’t writing history’s greatest books? There’s no better way to stave off a case of writer’s block than to play a rousing game of cricket. That seemed to be the motivation of a cadre of famous writers who formed the most literary-talented cricket team in history. J.M. Barrie…

Keep reading

Discover more from Commonplace Fun Facts

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply