T.S. Eliot (1888-1965) may have been a brilliant poet, author, and playwright, but as a judge of other authors, he was far from infallible. When given a chance to review one manuscript, in particular, he wrote off as unpublishable a work that was destined to become a classic.
Eliot was working at the publishing firm Faber & Faber in 1944. He received a manuscript from a promising author. He read it and determined it was unsuitable for publication. He wrote the rejection letter to the aspiring author, noting that the manuscript “is a distinguished piece of writing; that the fable is very skilfully handled, and that the narrative keeps one’s interest on its own plane – and that is something very few authors have achieved since Gulliver.”
Despite this, Eliot told the disappointed author that Faber & Faber would not be publishing his book. “I think my own dissatisfaction with this… is that the effect is simply one of negation. It ought to excite some sympathy with what the author wants, as well as sympathy with his objections to something: and the positive point of view… is not convincing,” he said in his letter.
Fortunately, the author was not too discouraged and sought another opinion. That is why Secker & Warburg publishers were able to release George Orwell’s Animal Farm to the public in August 1945.
Perhaps Eliot was thinking of his own limitations when he observed, “Some editors are failed writers, but so are most writers.”
“It seems I have spent a lifetime of mouthing mechanically, ‘Say thank you. Sit up straight. Use your napkin. Close your mouth when you chew. Don’t lean back in your chair.’ Just when I finally got my husband squared away, the kids came along.” — Erma BombeckKeep reading
One of the most famous poems in American literature started as something quite different. The eponymous talking bird who is featured in Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Raven” was originally cast as a multi-colored feathered cousin.Keep reading
At the time of this writing, the world’s attention is on the events surrounding the death of Queen Elizabeth II and the ascendency of King Charles III to the throne. One can’t help but wonder what it would be like to be born into royalty and what that life would be like. It doesn’t take…Keep reading