Nostalgic Christmas illustration of a delighted boy writing a letter to Santa on the carpet, surrounded by Christmas catalogs with circled toys, beside a Christmas tree and vintage television.

There was a time when the Christmas season did not begin with an online sale, a suspiciously early pumpkin-spice commercial, or an email announcing that a retailer had thoughtfully selected several hundred items we apparently could not live without. Christmas began when the mailman delivered the catalog. Not just any catalog, mind you. The Christmas catalog: a thick, glorious, brightly illustrated monument to childhood ambition, conveniently disguised as something parents might use to order bath towels.

For generations of American children, the arrival of the Sears Wish Book, the JCPenney Christmas catalog, or its Montgomery Ward counterpart was an event. We didn’t merely look through those pages. We studied them, marked them, memorized them, and developed elaborate purchasing strategies on behalf of adults who had not requested our financial advice. The toy section was a kingdom of possibility, and for a few wonderful weeks, owning everything in it seemed like a perfectly reasonable Christmas objective.

Today, a child can search for a toy, watch seventeen videos reviewing it, compare prices, and add it to a digital wish list before breakfast. The old Christmas catalogs worked differently. They required patience, imagination, and the ability to endure the terrible uncertainty of not knowing whether a certain toy was even remotely within Santa’s operating budget. Their magic wasn’t confined to what arrived under the tree. Much of it happened beforehand, while we were turning the pages.

Before the Sears Wish Book, Shopping Was a Geographical Problem

To understand why Christmas catalogs became so important, we have to visit nineteenth-century America, when getting to a store could be considerably more complicated than remembering where we parked. City residents enjoyed department stores and specialty shops, but families in rural communities often depended on general stores with limited selections and prices they could do little to negotiate. If the local merchant didn’t stock what you wanted, your options included traveling a considerable distance, settling for something else, or developing a more realistic relationship with your desires.

Enter Aaron Montgomery Ward, a traveling salesman who had observed the disadvantages faced by rural shoppers. In 1872, he began selling goods directly to customers by mail. His first Montgomery Ward catalog was a single sheet listing 163 products. It was not exactly the sort of publication a child would spend an entire December studying. Nevertheless, the idea was revolutionary: instead of making a long journey to see what a store might have, shoppers could examine what a distant merchant was offering and place an order from home.

The concept caught on remarkably quickly. By 1876, Ward’s catalog had expanded to 152 pages and approximately 3,000 items. Richard Sears and his associates subsequently built a competing mail-order empire, eventually producing catalogs so comprehensive that the term department store seemed inadequate. Clothing, watches, furniture, tools, musical instruments, farm equipment, and enough household supplies to keep several generations busy were all available between two covers. The catalog promised that living far from Chicago no longer meant living far from almost everything Chicago could sell you.

Of course, having a catalog and receiving the merchandise were two separate accomplishments. Railroads carried goods between distant markets, while improvements in the postal system made ordering and delivery progressively easier. The introduction of rural free delivery in 1896 began bringing mail directly to rural households, initially on an experimental basis, and the establishment of parcel post in 1913 opened further possibilities for shipping merchandise through the mail. Families who once had to make a substantial trip just to collect their letters could increasingly conduct business without leaving the farm. The mail-order revolution was underway, and the American public was discovering the convenience of shopping without having to put on respectable clothes.

The variety of merchandise eventually became almost comical. Sears even sold entire houses through its Modern Homes program, which operated from 1908 to 1940. Buyers selected a design, ordered the materials, and received a building kit delivered by railroad. An especially interesting account of a Sears kit house in Pennsylvania describes a family hauling the materials from the train station and assembling their home in 1921. Imagine opening your package and discovering that the instructions begin, in effect, with ‘build the house.’ Suddenly the assembly required on a toy bicycle seems rather manageable.

1933 — The Christmas Book Gets Its Own Spotlight

In 1933, during the Great Depression, Sears issued its first dedicated Christmas Book. It was 87 pages long, which sounds modest beside the later editions but was still an impressive collection of things a household might wish to buy at a time when money was painfully scarce. According to the Sears catalog history, 25 pages featured toys and the remaining 62 offered gifts for adults. Even at the beginning, the company had clearly recognized an important economic truth: children might supply the enthusiasm, but adults controlled the checkbook.

The selections sound wonderfully peculiar today. There were Lionel electric trains, a Miss Pigtails doll, a battery-powered toy automobile, a Mickey Mouse watch, fruitcakes, chocolates, and live singing canaries. Yes, live canaries. Apparently, the ideal Christmas gift for some households was a small bird whose principal talent was making noise without the assistance of batteries. We are left to wonder how many parents later reconsidered the wisdom of that purchase at approximately five o’clock in the morning.

There is a small naming complication. Sears customers had already been calling its large general catalogs the ‘Wish Book’ or ‘Book of Wishes’ before 1933. The Christmas edition gradually became so closely associated with that affectionate nickname that Sears officially adopted the Wish Book name in 1968. The company had spent decades selling wishes without ever needing to explain the concept. The public had already handled the branding, presumably free of charge.

When the Christmas Catalog Became a Holiday Institution

The period after World War II provided ideal conditions for the Christmas catalog to flourish. More families had money to spend, manufacturers offered increasingly elaborate toys, and national advertising created a shared vocabulary of things children were absolutely certain they required. Television brought the newest products directly into living rooms. The catalog then supplied an attractively illustrated place where a child could find those products, determine what else went with them, and present an ambitious acquisition plan to the family.

By 1968, the Sears Wish Book had grown to an astonishing 605 pages, including 225 pages of toys and 380 pages of other gifts. The toy section alone was more than twice the length of the entire 1933 Christmas Book. It was also the portion of the publication most likely to be examined with the seriousness usually reserved for an upcoming examination or a national intelligence briefing. A child might know the location of a favorite toy by page number while remaining entirely unable to remember where the math homework had gone.

Sears wasn’t alone. Montgomery Ward offered its own holiday merchandise, while JCPenney entered the catalog business in 1963 and developed a formidable Christmas-shopping presence. Other retailers and specialty stores also distributed seasonal books. Competition meant that families might have several catalogs around the house, each containing a different arrangement of tempting possibilities. If one retailer inexplicably omitted the object of a child’s obsession, another might redeem the entire industry.

The 1960s through the 1980s represented the golden age of the Christmas catalog. By then, these enormous publications had become a cherished holiday tradition, with increasingly elaborate toy sections designed to capture the imaginations of children and the disposable incomes of their parents. And the catalogs just kept getting bigger. By 1992, the Sears Christmas catalog had swollen to more than 800 pages, offering enough merchandise to satisfy nearly every conceivable Christmas wish—and several that no reasonable person should have conceived in the first place.

One of the most remarkable things about the Christmas catalogs was how early they arrived. A recollection preserved by the Harvey County Historical Society describes children eagerly anticipating the Sears and JCPenney catalogs in mid-August. August! While other children were still enjoying the final weeks of summer vacation, an entire generation of future accountants and procurement specialists was already compiling Christmas wish lists. Santa might have been enjoying a well-deserved vacation, but his fourth-quarter purchasing requirements were already being finalized.

The Toy Pages — An Entire Universe, Conveniently Numbered

Now we reach the part of the catalog that actually mattered to the average eight-year-old. The introductory pages of robes, perfume, slippers, and cookware could be negotiated at considerable speed. Then came the toys, usually arranged in colorful spreads packed with images, prices, stock numbers, and descriptions. There were dolls and miniature kitchens, trains and racing cars, chemistry sets, sports equipment, board games, bicycles, and elaborate playsets. A single open spread could contain enough potential Christmas presents to occupy a child’s imagination until the following August.

Most of the images in this article show toys that were popular with boys. Before anyone accuses us of overlooking half the toy department, we should acknowledge that the Christmas catalogs contained an impressive assortment of dolls, dollhouses, play kitchens, and other toys traditionally marketed to girls. We recognize their importance and fully support the right of little girls to have extravagant Christmas wish lists of their own.

Unfortunately, our fragile masculinity has never been particularly comfortable with pages containing an excessive amount of pink. Even today, we can practically feel our testosterone levels dropping whenever we’re confronted with a double-page spread of dolls, miniature kitchen appliances, and frilly accessories. Consequently, the photographs accompanying this article lean heavily toward toys traditionally marketed to boys. This is not intended as a slight against the other half of the toy department. It is merely a necessary precaution to protect what remains of our rugged he-man persona, which, frankly, was never all that impressive to begin with.

In the earlier decades, electric trains were among the most glamorous offerings. Lionel locomotives promised a miniature transportation network with switches, freight cars, bridges, and enough track to colonize the living-room floor. Dolls and dollhouses offered their own complete domestic worlds, while building sets invited children to produce ambitious constructions that might remain standing for several minutes. Bicycles appeared with gleaming chrome and extravagant promises of independence. A child could admire them all without considering such dreary adult concerns as storage space, maintenance, or the cost of replacing batteries.

The 1950s and 1960s brought new personalities and adventures. Cowboy gear reflected the popularity of Westerns, while Barbie, introduced in 1959, developed a growing assortment of clothing, accessories, friends, and real estate. G.I. Joe arrived in 1964 and helped define the modern action figure. Space-age toys promised rockets, robots, and scientific futures that would apparently be available shortly after Christmas morning. It was a time when a child’s bedroom could resemble both a suburban neighborhood and a military-industrial complex.

The selections also tracked the country’s entertainment habits. As we’ve explored in our history of Saturday morning cartoons, children’s television and toy marketing became increasingly intertwined. A cartoon character could move from the screen to the catalog and finally to a bedroom carpet, frequently accompanied by several accessories that were, naturally, sold separately. Catalog pages transformed advertisements into something that could be revisited and studied long after the commercial ended.

By the late 1970s, Star Wars had given toy manufacturers an unusually expansive galaxy to merchandise. Figures, spaceships, vehicles, and playsets invited children to reenact the movies, revise the plots, or create incidents that would have required extensive explanations to the Rebel Alliance. The 1979 Sears Wish Book offered an impressive assortment of Star Wars merchandise, including a Boba Fett action figure that appeared before the character made his theatrical-film debut in 1980. Meanwhile, JCPenney offered its own extensive selection of science-fiction toys, including the Micronauts, whose elaborate vehicles and playsets promised adventures in miniature universes. No wonder so many parents learned that purchasing one action figure was merely the first step of a much larger commitment.

The 1970s also introduced a challenger to the traditional toy chest: electronic entertainment. In 1975, Sears partnered with Atari to bring a home version of Pong to American living rooms under the Tele-Games name. Subsequent catalogs increasingly featured video game systems, handheld electronic diversions, and cartridges that promised hours of entertainment. The Christmas list was beginning to include objects that required a television, a power supply, and occasionally a family discussion about who was allowed to use either. A generation had moved from winding up toy robots to demanding machines with actual circuitry. Childhood entertainment was entering the electronic age, and parents were discovering that batteries were no longer the most expensive part of the problem.

Then came the 1980s, when the toy industry became extraordinarily skilled at turning an entire afternoon of television into a list of purchases. Transformers, Masters of the Universe, electronic games, and Nintendo systems joined old favorites. Cabbage Patch Kids became the center of a spectacular early-1980s buying frenzy, a phenomenon we’ve previously examined in our history of toy crazes. Every parent who had promised to try to find one discovered that ‘try’ was doing an enormous amount of work in that sentence.

Page 483 of the 1979 JCPenney Christmas catalog advertising Micronauts toys and Giant Shogun Warriors, including the Micropolis Megacity, Hornetroid, Terraphant, Star Searcher, and action figures.
Micronauts and Giant Shogun Warriors share page 483 of the 1979 JCPenney Christmas catalog. They inhabited different fictional universes and had little reason to join forces, but at least they could coexist peacefully on the same catalog page. Whether they maintained that peaceful relationship after arriving in a child’s bedroom was another matter entirely.

The Sacred Art of Circling Toys

Possessing the catalog was only the beginning. Every household seemed to develop its own system for managing the book. Some children were allowed to circle desirable items. Others folded page corners, inserted scraps of paper, or compiled lists containing carefully transcribed descriptions and page numbers. Particularly enterprising youngsters employed several methods simultaneously, apparently concerned that a single notification channel might fail to penetrate the adult bureaucracy. These were the earliest versions of the online wish list, except the technology was a pencil and an optimistic misunderstanding of the family’s finances.

First, of course, came the dispute over who got the catalog. In a household with several children, there might be an informal rotation, a formal arrangement, or a brief but decisive wrestling match. The successful claimant would settle into a chair or onto the carpet and begin searching through the pages. Before long, the book developed a familiar geography: here were the bicycles, there were the games, and somewhere in the middle was the single most important object in the known universe.

Page corners gradually became soft. Covers bent. The binding weakened under the pressure of repeated consultation. A genuinely well-loved Christmas catalog did not remain pristine. By December, it might resemble a document recovered from a shipwreck, except that every page concerning a particular action figure had somehow survived. The wear was not neglect. It was evidence of sustained research, conducted by investigators with powerful motivation and very little purchasing authority.

There was also the peculiar pleasure of wanting things one knew were unlikely to appear. The enormous electric train layout, the elaborate dollhouse, the expensive bicycle, or the video game system might be completely beyond the family budget. But the catalog didn’t ask for a financial disclosure before allowing us to dream. It could make an ordinary afternoon feel like a visit to a store where nothing was off-limits, provided nobody insisted that the merchandise actually come home.

For parents and grandparents, the marked pages served another function. They provided a glimpse into what a child was imagining and offered a practical guide to gift shopping. An adult might look at the same page and see not a heroic space adventure but a price, a delivery deadline, and the question of whether the toy would survive past New Year’s Day. The Christmas catalog brought those two perspectives together. It was a shared book in which children dreamed extravagantly and adults attempted to make at least a few of those dreams fit within reality.

How Christmas Shopping Actually Worked Before the Internet

Of course, a Christmas catalog wasn’t simply a wish-producing device. It was also an operating system for purchasing merchandise, and using it demanded a level of organization that would test some of our modern shopping habits. Customers selected an item, checked its size or color, noted its catalog number, and worked out the price. Depending on the retailer and the era, they could fill out an order form, mail it with payment, telephone an order, or work through a catalog department at a store or local sales office.

Earlier generations often mailed orders accompanied by checks or money orders. There were no reassuring little delivery animations showing a tiny truck inching toward the house. A successful transaction required accurate information, a functioning distribution system, and the willingness to wait. Ordering the wrong size or miscopying an item number could create a problem that took considerably longer to resolve than an awkward conversation with an online chatbot. And unlike a modern web page, the printed catalog could not instantly display ‘out of stock’ beside the object you wanted most.

The Sears system was a remarkable logistical undertaking. Warehouses filled orders, packed boxes, and sent merchandise through postal, railroad, and later commercial delivery networks. Customers might receive purchases at home or arrange pickup through a store or catalog office. Christmas made everything more suspenseful. Parents had to allow sufficient time for ordering and delivery, make substitutions if a desired item was unavailable, and then somehow conceal the results from the very children who had been studying the catalog like detectives.

Meanwhile, shopping in person retained its own pleasures. Department stores displayed holiday decorations, toy demonstrations, elaborate windows, and sometimes a Santa Claus who took time out of his busy holiday schedule to hear children’s Christmas wishes personally. Never mind that these same children had probably already mailed him their lists, provided copies to Mom and Dad, and repeatedly discussed their priorities at the dinner table. There was something reassuring about looking the jolly old elf directly in the eye and making absolutely certain he understood the assignment.

Shopping malls later offered their own version of this spectacle, as we’ve seen in our history of the rise and fall of American shopping malls. The catalog did something different: it let the holiday marketplace move into the family home and remain there for weeks.

Modern online shopping can be wonderfully efficient, particularly if one enjoys discovering on December 23 that an item can be delivered by breakfast. But the old process stretched out the experience. Browsing, choosing, ordering, waiting, and finally opening the package occupied different parts of the season. Each stage supplied its own anticipation. It was inconvenient by today’s standards, but inconvenience occasionally has excellent public-relations skills when viewed through nostalgia.

What the Old Christmas Catalogs Reveal About Us

Open catalogs from different decades and the toys provide a surprisingly detailed history of American childhood. Cowboy outfits give way to astronauts; mechanical amusements share space with electronic games; characters from television migrate into elaborate plastic franchises. Changes in materials, technology, marketing, and popular entertainment unfold across the printed pages. A stack of old Wish Books can function like an unofficial museum, albeit one in which the exhibits repeatedly encourage us to buy something.

Vintage JCPenney catalog page showing four boys modeling Six Million Dollar Man, Spider-Man, Bruce Lee, and Star Trek pajamas, with a Hulk shirt pictured above and prices from $6.50 to $8.
The Christmas catalog even made shopping for clothes fun when pajamas apparently imbued the wearer with superpowers. These JCPenney designs featured the Six Million Dollar Man, Spider-Man, Bruce Lee, and Star Trek. Sadly, the catalog offered no warranty covering actual superhuman abilities.

The books even connect to some unlikely corners of Christmas history. Montgomery Ward wasn’t merely a catalog competitor; in 1939, one of its advertising employees created Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer for a holiday promotional booklet. We’ve told the full story of how a department store gave Rudolph his famous red nose. It is comforting to know that a character associated with the pure wonder of Christmas emerged from the same commercial universe that sold hosiery, furniture, and discount cookware.

When the Wish Book Began to Fade

The Christmas catalog didn’t disappear because children suddenly stopped wanting toys. Retail competition intensified, specialty toy stores and discount chains expanded, and shopping malls changed how families bought gifts. Catalog operations were expensive to print, distribute, and maintain. Computerized inventory systems and eventually online shopping offered alternatives that were often faster and cheaper. Slowly, the enormous book that once brought the department store to your doorstep became less necessary.

Sears closed its traditional general catalog operation in 1993, and the familiar full-size Christmas Wish Book also ended its original run around that time. But this was not an immediate extinction. Sears later experimented with Wishbook.com, interactive online editions, and shorter printed revivals. In 2007, the company introduced a 188-page revival of the Wish Book, and another smaller edition appeared in 2017. The name had become too closely tied to holiday memories to disappear without an occasional encore.

JCPenney’s catalog business followed its own path. Its major catalogs remained significant well into the internet era, and the company discontinued its traditional Big Book after the 2009 fall-winter edition, while continuing smaller specialty publications for a time. In an almost perfect example of retail terminology attempting to negotiate with reality, JCPenney later mailed a smaller printed merchandise booklet while insisting it was not actually a catalog. Apparently the distinction depended on how vigorously the marketing department objected to the word.

The Best Part Was the Wishing

It’s tempting to conclude that Christmas was simply better when it arrived in a thick paper catalog, but nostalgia is an unreliable accountant. Not every toy was affordable. Not every order arrived in time. Some children received precisely what they had wanted, while others had to master the difficult art of looking delighted when Santa apparently misread their carefully prepared wish lists and delivered underwear instead of the requested spaceship. The wonderful feeling we remember was never a guarantee that every Christmas morning would deliver everything promised by those colorful pages.

What the old Christmas catalogs did offer was time. Time to study, compare, circle, reconsider, and imagine. Time for siblings to argue over who got the book next, for parents to search for clues, and for a child to revisit the same picture so often that every detail became familiar. The toy might eventually arrive in a cardboard box, but the adventure had begun weeks earlier, sometimes while summer was still lingering outside the window.

The modern equivalent can place an item in our shopping cart in seconds. The Sears Wish Book made us spend an entire season thinking about what might be inside a box we hadn’t even received. One approach is unquestionably more efficient. The other gave generations of children the rare pleasure of believing, at least for a while, that anything pictured on page 247 was possible. So we have a question for our readers: What toy did you circle in the Christmas catalog year after year, and did you finally find it beneath the tree?


You may also enjoy…


Discover more from Commonplace Fun Facts

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply