The Background For the Houdini Death Prophecy

The early 20th century was time when the line between reality and the supernatural was blurred. From fortune teller booths in the city streets to the parlors of the wealthiest homeowners, the hopeful and the heartbroken sought spiritualists and mediums to pierce the veil between the living and the dead. The more desperate the seeker, the more likely he or she would fall prey to a con artist. Countless fortunes were predicted, but many more fortunes were lost by those who naively trusted in scam spiritualists.

One of the fiercest warriors in the battle to protect the public was Harry Houdini. The master illusionist and escape artist waged a relentless war against fraudulent spiritualists. Despite his belief in the possibility of communicating with spirits, he was deeply disturbed by the swindlers preying on the vulnerable.

Houdini’s crusade wasn’t a solitary one. The number of fortune-tellers and séance conductors who were preying on the public was so great that Congress considered regulating the burgeoning industry. Houdini lent his support to legislation designed to shield the public from these deceitful mediums.

Senate Bill Against Spiritualists

The proposed legislation was H.R. 8989:

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled. That subchapter 5 of the Code of Law for the District of Columbia, as amended to June 7, 1924, relating to offenses against public policy, be and the same is hereby, amended by adding thereto a new section, as follows: “Any person pretending to tell fortunes for reward or compensation where lost or stolen goods may be found; any person who, by game or device, sleight of hand, pretending, fortune telling, or by any trick or other means, by the use of cards or other Implements or Instruments, fraudulently obtains from another person money or property or reward, property of and description; and person pretending to remove spells, or to sell charms for protection, or to unite the separated, shall be considered a disorderly person. Any person violating the provisions of this law shall be punished by a fine not to exceed $250 or by imprisonment not to exceed six months, or by both such fine and imprisonment.”

The hearings began on February 26 (Read the entire record of the testimony before the Senate here). It was a spectacle to behold. For four days, the proceedings spiraled into a chaotic theater of insults and even physical altercations. In the midst of this pandemonium, the ugly specter of anti-Semitism emerged. One spiritualist, in a venomous diatribe, aimed a thinly veiled slur at Houdini and the bill’s sponsor, Representative Sol Bloom:

“Judas betrayed Christ. He was a Jew, and I want to say that this bill is being put through by two—well, you can use your opinion; I am not making an assertion.”

Knowing the bill faced many obstacles, Houdini threw his support behind it. Ever the showman, he had a trick up his sleeve. Before the hearings, Houdini had enlisted private investigator Rose Mackenberg to delve into the murky underworld of Washington D.C.’s spiritualists. Her findings were nothing short of explosive.

Mackenberg uncovered that high-ranking politicians, including senators and even Presidents Woodrow Wilson, Warren G. Harding, and Calvin Coolidge, were regular clients of these mediums. The White House itself had hosted numerous séances. Notably, “Madame” Marcia Champney, a leading figure among the spiritualists, had been the spiritual advisor to Florence Harding, the wife of President Harding, allegedly predicting both his election and untimely death.

To Houdini, these revelations were damning. Spiritualism was not a harmless diversion or a respectable belief system but a grave threat to democracy. How could the American public trust leaders who were under the sway of fraudulent mediums?

In his testimony, Houdini declared, “This thing they call Spiritualism, wherein a medium intercommunicates with the dead, is a fraud from start to finish…[mediums are all] mental degenerates or deliberate cheats.”

With his characteristic flair, he held up an envelope, challenging anyone to correctly determine its contents. This was met with bemusement by the committee members, who largely believed Houdini was overreacting. Amusing exchanges followed, like when Representative Frank Reid of Illinois guessed one of the phrases in the envelope. Houdini retorted, “That was a guess; you are no clairvoyant!” Reid replied, “Oh yes I am,” eliciting chuckles.

The debate over H.R. 8989 devolved into ad hominem attacks and constant outbursts. Mediums lashed out at Houdini, who unrolled reams of evidence, including a 50-foot scroll. During breaks intended to restore order, scuffles erupted in the hallways. The theatrics peaked when Houdini challenged the mediums to produce a single verifiable psychic phenomenon, waving an envelope stuffed with $10,000. Madame Marcia claimed the money was hers, having predicted Harding’s election and death, but the prediction remained unverifiable.

Despite the dramatic evidence and Houdini’s impassioned pleas, his bill failed to pass. The overall view of the committee was expressed by member Ralph Gilbert of Kentucky, who remarked, “I believe in Santa Claus and I believe in fairies, in a way…and [Houdini] is taking the matter entirely too seriously.” Even so, Houdini’s true aim was never legal reform. He sought to expose the massive fraud of spiritualism to the American public, and in this, he succeeded. The hearings shattered the spiritualist movement’s credibility, leading to a significant decline in its popularity.

There was one curious footnote to H.R. 8989 that must be considered. In the heat of the debate about the legitimacy of Madame Marcia’s abilities, she made a defiant prediction. She told Houdini that he would be dead before November. Perhaps those who heard her words in February chuckled and dismissed them, but something would happen that caused those who were present to remember the eerie prediction.

On October 22, 1926, while in his dressing room at the Princess Theatre in Montreal, Houdini was approached by McGill University student Jocelyn Gordon Whitehead. Whitehead asked if it was true that punches to the stomach did not harm Houdini. Before Houdini could prepare himself, Whitehead delivered a series of powerful blows to his abdomen, rupturing Houdini’s appendix. Houdini refused medical attention despite excruciating pain and a high fever.

Halloween Fulfillment of the Houdini Death Prophecy

The next day, while performing in Detroit, Houdini’s condition worsened. He was rushed to Grace Hospital, where he underwent two surgeries, but the infection was too advanced. Harry Houdini died on Halloween, October 31, 1926—just as Madame Marcia had predicted.

Was it a coincidence or evidence of inexplicable foreknowledge? Either way, Madame Marcia had the last laugh.

Curiously, despite his public battle against spiritualism, Houdini remained privately open to the idea of an afterlife and communication with the dead. After his death, his wife Bess held séances on the anniversary of his passing, hoping to hear from him. After ten years, she conceded:

“Houdini did not come through. … I do not believe that Houdini can come back to me, or to anyone.”

Yet, the tradition of Houdini séances persists, with devotees gathering every Halloween night in hopes of receiving a message from the Great Beyond. Knowing Houdini, he is probably rolling in his escape-proof grave.

---